‘All Marketers Are Liars‘ is a provocatively entertaining book about marketing and human nature. Seth Godin has once again applied his reliable formula for publishing success:

1. Pick a traditional and well accepted marketing concept
2. Write about it from a totally new perspective
3. Make the book easy to read and include a lot of examples
4. Give the book an intriguing title
5. Sell a lot of books

In ‘Purple Cow’ the basic concept was differentiation (nothing new in itself, after all, people had been talking about positioning and unique selling propositions for decades). In ‘All Marketers are Liars’ Seth’s premise is based on these two well established marketing concepts:

1. It is harder to make something and then try to sell it, than it is to first find out what people want and then give it to them.
2. It is very difficult (and expensive) to try to change people’s perception once it is already formed.

The new ‘angle’ being explored, though, is that most of the time those perceptions are based on emotions that go against objective facts. The recipe for successful marketing, says Godin, is to find a large enough group of people with a particular world view, and offer them a product that caters and reinforces that world view.

Judging by some reader reviews, some people seem to have taken offense to Seth’s thesis, implying that it encourages dishonesty in marketing. I don’t subscribe to that point of view. Giving people exactly what they want, even though objective facts suggest that they should want something else is not being dishonest.

To illustrate Seth’s thesis I’ll give you an example: suppose that you have two identical watches, one of them is made in Switzerland and the other one is made in China. If you ask people which one is better, I bet that nine out of ten will answer ‘the Swiss watch’.

The objective of the Swiss watch maker is to sell watches. Are they supposed to go around telling everybody that the Chinese watch is as good as theirs? Of course not. The Swiss watch maker’s advertising will most likely make extensive use of marketing signals that reinforce the world view of the nine people who picked the Swiss watch: their magazine ads will probably display pictures of their watch with a backdrop of a quaint Swiss village surrounded by the Alps and the Swiss cross prominently displayed somewhere on the page.

Now, if the Swiss watch maker decided to relocate their manufacturing plant to China and continued to use the same marketing signals in their advertising their customers would cry foul. If they also intentionally and openly lied about the country of origin of the watch they would be committing fraud. Seth Godin voices a strong opinion against these two scenarios, the first one because it would be “unauthentic” and the second one because it would be outright illegal and unethical.

All Marketers are Liars’ is a quick and entertaining read (you can probably breeze through it from cover to cover on your average plane ride) and it will leave you with a valuable takeaway on which to base your marketing strategy.

Del.icio.us / Digg / Stumble it!

Subscribe